The fantasy of surprising your loved one with an adorable puppy under the tree on Christmas morning may seem like the perfect gift….but is it really? Humane societies, shelter workers, veterinarians, the American Kennel Club, reputable breeders and rescue groups across the country resoundingly say NO!

  poster stop danish puppy mill


Animals should never be given as gifts at any time of the year and the holidays are, in fact, the worst time to bring a dog of any age into your home and your life.

New puppies and dogs require extra attention and a stable environment which the holiday season does not permit. Caring for the puppy’s round-the-clock feeding and house training needs as well as finding time to comfort and reassure an insecure pup amidst the holiday chaos is an impossible task.

Just think about a few of the potentially hazardous and no-win scenarios to which you will be subjecting a young Christmas puppy:

rudolph buttonDoors left open with people coming and going giving a new dog the opportunity to run away — a catastrophic situation for your pup and your family not to mention your loss of money;

rudolph buttonPup will be underfoot and could be stepped on causing an injury resulting in a broken paw or leg;

rudolph buttonHousehold will not be in any routine which means the pup will not establish a routine for house training — a situation that will add extra time to the overall house training process and unnecessary stress for you and your dog. Also, remember that winter weather generally does not provide the optimum conditions for house training.

rudolph buttonNumerous additional household safety hazards for your puppy due to holiday decorations, gifts and festivities. For more information, please read Holiday Safety.

rudolph buttonThe all-important introduction and transition period to forge the bond between you and your pup will be seriously compromised. Pets need to have the right start in a family or bad habits can develop.

rudolph buttonHoliday activities will impair your ability to adequately supervise the interaction of the new puppy and your children — the risk of a sick, frightened, injured or confused pup biting your child is very high.

Puppy Mill DogsPuppies given as gifts are usually impulse purchases from pet stores because reputable breeders do not sell puppies during the holiday season. A dog is not a toy that can be returned or discarded. And the result of making the wrong choice when selecting a living being as a gift is tragic. Ask any shelter worker or rescue volunteer about the influx of ill, untrained and unwanted dogs in the holiday aftermath.

No matter how much you think your loved one would enjoy this “surprise”, you should never presume to make this decision for another person. Getting a pet is a lifelong commitment. Given that many breeds can live well into their teen years, this is a major decision requiring emotional stability and financial responsibility — it is a decision that can not be taken lightly.

This is an important decision that needs to involve the entire family and can not be made in a hurry. It takes time to research the appropriate breed, choose a reputable breeder and select the perfect pup. The wait will be well worth it! No one should ever be denied the joy of selecting his or her own dog.

We highly recommend you place a “Puppy Gift Package” instead of a live pup under the Christmas tree. This is a fun gift to create and a fun gift to receive. This gift package can consist of a wide variety of items such as a crate, a gift certificate entitling the recipient to the “dog of your choice”, a stuffed dog complete with a big red bow, gift certificates for the first veterinary check-up and puppy socialization classes, dog toys, bowls, leash, collar, brush, comb, books about dog care and dog breeds, video on dog training, donation to a rescue group or shelter — be creative and have fun!

Mill dogs

You may discover by your loved one’s reaction on Christmas morning that the idea of a new puppy and the accompanying responsibility is less than thrilling and definitely not wanted. However by

giving the “Puppy Gift Package” nothing is really lost. All the items can be returned to the mall or donated to your local shelter or rescue group. Then together you and your loved one can pick out something really wanted.

On the other hand, if a puppy is really desired, your “Puppy Gift Package” will be greatly appreciated. Then after the holidays, when life has returned to a normal pace, together you and your family can thoughtfully begin the process of selecting the right dog and giving your dog the right start. Your time and effort will be greatly rewarded with a faithful companion who will give you a lifetime of love and devotion.


Recommended Reading:

Merry Christmas from Ye Olde Puppy Shoppe

‘Twas the Night Before Christmas

Another Variation of ‘Twas the Night Before Christmas

Dogs Are Not Gifts

Before You Buy A German Shepherd Puppy




Used with permission. Written by Sandy Gilmer, San Francisco Bay West Highland White Terrier Club.
Reproduction other than for personal home use is prohibited without permission of the author.


Share Button